Potty training the Bean was a piece of cake. We bought Lightning McQueen underwear, took off his diaper one afternoon, and after two accidents, he was good to go. He wore diapers for a while longer at naptime, and a bit longer than that for overnights. But by the time he was four, we were totally done with diapers.
We delayed starting potty training with the Little One because he operates on a different program than his older brother. The Bean was very motivated by rewards for behavior - pee in the potty, get a sticker. Poop in the potty, get a matchbox car (this was a harder trick to master, so got a bigger reward). He would negotiate for more stickers, stickers for just trying...you name it, I was was willing to give him a sticker for almost anything relating to getting out of diapers. Wash your hands without being asked? Sticker! Remember to flush the toliet? Sticker! Stand up to pee and don't miss the toliet?
Two stickers! We had an 11x20 sheet of paper taped to the pantry door with so many stickers on it, it eventually collapse under it's own weight.
Now, the Little One? He doesn't work quite like that. We decided he was ready for potty training and bought some Thomas the Train underwear. Very exciting! The Little One refused to even put them on.
"Come on, don't you want to try them out? Be like your big brother?"
"No." He shrugged, shook his head emphatically, so I would be clear on his position.
"I'll give you a sticker!"
"No!" and he walked away, effectively dismissing the conversation.
The next day, "Little One, do you want to try sitting on the potty today?"
"No Mommy."
The next day, "Little One, today's the day! Let's try the potty. You can stand up like big brother and Daddy do!"
"No, Mommy."
A week goes by, and I try again, "Okay, buddy! Before you get in the bath tonight, let's try sitting on the potty. No bath until you at least try to pee in the potty for me."
"No, Mommy. I not gonna do it."
Now, I'm starting to feel like I have to do something to jump start this. I mean, really? He's almost three. I'm not asking him to donate a kidney! Just to give up diaper changes, which he loathes anyway!
"Why not? Won't you at least try? What if I give you a sticker?"
"No sticker."
"Lollipop?"
"No."
"What about a cookie? I'll go downstairs and get you a cookie right now if you'll try the potty. You don't even have to pee in it. Just sit on it."
"No, Mommy. I not."
"
Why?!"
"Because I not want to."
"What can I do to make you want to? What do you want?"
"Nuffing, Mommy. I not want anyfing. I not pee in potty."
And that was that. How do you argue with that? I let it go for awhile before we started again, a couple of weeks later. And the result was exactly the same. The bribes I offered got more outrageous. After the usual sticker, lollipop, cookie, I upped the ante.
"What if I take you to the store and let you pick out a car - any car you want?"
"Any car?" I am elated at this point. This is the first time he hasn't shut me down outright! We're making progress!!
"Yes, Little One! Any car you want! You've just got to pee on the potty and wear your underwear for the rest of the afternoon."
He thinks about it for a minute, then, "No."
ARGH!!!!!
Then, one evening, as the boys are getting in the bathtub, the Bean goes pee like he always does, and the Little One suddenly takes an interest in the toliet paper his brother is using.
"Mommy," he pulls off a piece of toliet paper and shows it to me. "Can I flush this down the hole?"
"You want to flush that toliet paper down the potty?" Bells and lights are going off in my head. Oh yes, I'm having one of those parenting moments where you suddenly feel like you've got the answers to all the problems, ever!
"Yes, Mommy. Can I?"
"Sure, but you have to pee in the potty first. Then you can use the toliet paper to wipe yourself and flush the pee and the paper down the hole."
He shrugs, "Ok, Mommy. Can you help me sit?"
He now wears underwear most of the time and, though he has accidents periodically, he's getting really good about giving me enough warning to get him to the toliet in time.